Between a Court of Appeal Judgment & the Claim by Abuja Indigenes on the Recent Earth Tremor in Abuja: Have Our Ancestors Assumed the Role of Enforcers of Rule of Law? By Sylvester Udemezue)


In the morning of Sunday, September 09, 2018, I had posted on a WhatsApp forum, some three legal essays, one each written separately and at different times in 2015 by FESTUS KEYAMO (SAN), SYLVESTER UDEMEZUE, and JITI OGUNYE. Each of the three legal articles was obviously written, one in response to another.

Eminent Learned silk, Festus Keyamo had in his commentary published on May 15. 2015, argued that the Federal Government of Nigeria (FGN) had no obligation to appoint up to 36 or 37 Ministers at the same time for the Federal Republic, provided that the President ensured that before the end of his four-year tenure, he had appointed at least one Minister from each State of the Federation. According to the respected learned Senior Advocate, it does not matter if the President of the Federal Republic chooses to appoint some Ministers today and to remove them or some of them tomorrow, just in order to be able to touch all the States in the Federation during his tenure, in obedience to the provisions of the Constitution. His words:

“The long-held notion in Nigeria that the President of the Federal Republic of Nigeria is under an obligation to appoint at least thirty-seven (37) Ministers into his cabinet is not correct after all – at least by a holistic appreciation of the spirit and letters of the 1999 Constitution (as amended).”  (See 

In a rejoinder first published on November 04, 2015 in the Sun Newspapers, among others, under the title, “Why Nigeria Must Always Have A Minimum of Thirty-Seven (37) Ministers For the Government of the Federation,” SYLVESTER UDEMEZUE argued that the President of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (FRN) had an obligation to appoint at least one Federal Minister from each of the 36 States of the Federation and also another one from the Federal Capital Territory, Abuja, and that all these thirty-seven (37) Federal Ministers must be appointed simultaneously, so that they, all and each, would have the opportunity of sitting, consulting and deliberating together in the (Federal Executive Council (FEC) or) the Executive Council of the Federation (ECF), in a manner that ensures that the Executive Council of the Federation reflects at all times ”the Federal character of Nigeria  and  also guarantees the need to promote national unity, and also to command national loyalty, thereby ensuring that there shall be no predominance of persons from a few State or from a few ethnic or other sectional groups in that Government.”(see:

Mr Udemezue further argued that it was mandatory for the President to appoint at least one Minster from among indigenes of Abuja (the FCT) since section 299 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (CFRN), as amended, requires that “the provisions of the Constitution shall apply to the FCT, Abuja as if it were one of the States of the Federation.” (see UDEMEZUE’s opinion:

Then, in a separate, well-researched contribution, published on November 06, 2015, distinguished legal giant, Mr Jiti Ogunye, apparently disagreeing with Mr Udemezue’s position, insisted, inter alia, that the President was not under any constitutional obligation to appoint any indigene or Abuja as a Minister (See

All this was in 2015. And then, on January 15, 2018, a little over two years after these legal debates, and following an appeal in a court action earlier initiated by an Abuja-based Legal Practitioner, Muss Panya-Baba, who was said to have been in the forefront of advocacy for indigenous peoples of Abuja, whose ancestral homes and land were taken by the Federal Government in FG’s bid to relocate Nigeria’s Federal Capital from Lagos to Abuja, legal justice came for the Abuja indigenes. While ordering the President of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (FRN) to immediately appoint an indigene of Abuja as a Minister of the Federal Republic, the Nigerian Court of Appeal in a unanimous judgment (delivered on January 15 2018) reportedly declared as follows:

“The FCT Abuja Indigenes are entitled to Ministerial representation in the Federal Executive Council (FEC) as provided by the combined provisions of Sec. 147(3), 299, 14(3) & 42 of 1999 Constitution. The Persistent denial and refusal of past Presidents and current President to so appoint an Indigene of FCT Abuja as a Minister in the Federal Executive Council since May 1999 is tantamount to a gross violation of the said Constitutional rights including fundamental right against discrimination.”

This landmark judgment of the Court of Appeal is in total agreement with the earlier opinion of yours sincerely (Sylvester Udemezue) on the matter. Indeed, the lead judgment in the case completely agrees with Mr Udemezue that it is constitutionally mandatory to have appointed as a Minister at least one indigene of the FCT, Abuja. The judgment confirms also that the mandatory minimum number of Federal Ministers the Federal Republic of Nigeria must have at any time is thirty-seven (37).

ALSO READ   10 Reasons Why You Need a StartUp Lawyer

(See (see also

Abuja indigenes hailed the judgement and saw in it a ray of hope in their legal struggles. (see Then on Tuesday, January 22, 2018, some indigenes of Abuja, the Federal Capital Territory (FCT), called on the Federal Government to implement the judgment of the Court of Appeal by immediately appointing at least one Minister from among FCT indigenes. Mr Kamal Shuaibu, Coordinator of the Coalition of FCT Indigenous Associations (COFCTIA) who led the Coalition on a protest march to the National Assembly of the Federal Republic of Nigerian then called on the members of National Assembly to also prevail on the Federal Government to ensure that the judgment of the Court of Appeal was immediately implemented.  (See

Thereafter, nothing was again heard about developments on the issue, not until Sunday, September 09, 2018, when the issue was brought up on Legal Practice Discourse (LPD) Forum, Discuss Nigeria Forum (DNF) and on Legal Minds, with a call on LPDites (members of the Legal Practice Discourse Forum), DNFites  (members of Discourse Nigeria Forum), and  Legal Minds to have a look again at the arguments earlier advanced (in 2015) on the matter by FESTUS KEYAMO, SAN, SYLVESTER UDEMEZUE and JITI OGUNYE as well as the January 2018 judgement of the Court of Appeal on the matter. And to assist the proposed discussions, all the three separate arguments from these learned friends as well as a news report on the affected Court of Appeal judgment were reproduced as earlier published. The matter was however scarcely discussed.

Nigerians, and indeed the entire world, woke up the following day, Monday, September 10, 2018 to behold these shocking news headlines:

The Leadership Newspaper report went thus:

“Some natives of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT), Abuja under the platform of Coalition of FCT Indigenous Associations (CFCTIA), have claimed responsibility for last week’s earth tremor that occurred in some parts of Mpape community and Maitama district in the nation’s capital. A statement signed by the spokesman of the group, Yunusa Ahmadu Yusuf, warned residents to expect more of such disturbances in parts of the territory, unless the federal government addresses the injustices and marginalisation against the FCT natives. Yusuf stated that the presidency, especially the Aso Villa should expect an unprecedented earth disturbance, “if between now and October, 2018, an indigene of the territory is not appointed as a minister.”

Mr. Yunusa Ahmadu Yusuf continues:

“Some recent time past, the Abuja Original Inhabitants had threatened to invoke the spirit of their ancestor in the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) to join us in this genuine struggle to liberate our people from the dungeon of marginalization by the federal government.” 

(see:, in its version, quoting Mr. Yunusa Ahmadu Yusuf, continued thus:

“We have cried enough and we may have to divulge to other alternatives to agitate for our exclusion in the scheme of things. So, the FCT native’s ancestors are responsible for the recent earth disturbance in the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) ….. the natives have always maintained peace, with utmost believe in every central administration, but this peace offer has been neglected and abused. It is very regrettable that since our ethnic consensus to allow free government operation in the Federal Capital Territory (FCT), the government has not returned back the gesture, but rather have sought different means to squash and alienate us in our ancestral land. Today, we the Abuja original inhabitants wish to reiterate categorically that the struggle is not yet over and we will not relent until deliberate efforts by the FG are visibly recorded, which includes the appointment of an FCT native as a minister,” (see: 

Some Nigerian scientists have however tried to offer empirical explanations for tremor. Listen to Prof. Mosto Onuoha, the President of Nigerian Academy of Science (NAS):

ALSO READ   Child Defilement, Baba Ijesha, and the Law

“Persistent and uncontrolled blasting of rocks through the use of powerful explosives could lead to earth movements…. rock blasting may be responsible for the earth movements in Mpape and parts of Maitama, Abuja. The use of explosives to break or blast rocks would have vibrating power and ability to the last end of the rock. It will get to the stage that could be seen visibly and to the bottom of the ground where we cannot see but where the rock has ended. When this action is continuous, the vibration from the rocks blasted with explosives will be transmitted to the body-like water that is already settled under the ground. The release of the vibration in form of energy back to the earth will lead to earth-shaking.”(see

Earlier, in a statement released on September 6, 2018, the Federal Capital Territory Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) had tried to explain out the tremor, saying:

“…..the earth shaking could be as a result of earth tremors; a sign of seismic movement within the earth which can be caused by sudden breaks along a fault line releasing energy that cause the shaking. It also said that the movement could also have been caused by stress in underground rocks due to blasting and mining activities in an area.” (see: 

Notwithstanding the explanations offered by scientists for the earth tremor, I personally, respectfully, think the reported claim by FCT indigenes have thrown up some legal issues which I feel are urgently deserving of serious considerations with a view to finding a lasting solution to the lingering one-Federal-Minister-from-Abuja controversy:

  • Are there any legal, social and security implications of the continued non-implementation of the Court of Appeal judgement on appointment of a Minister from among the FCT indigenous people?
  • Could there really be any reasonable link between the recent Abuja earth tremor in Abuja and the controversy relating to appointment of a Minister from the FCT, as claimed by the Abuja indigenes?
  • Put differently, to what extent (if any) could it be correct (as claimed) that the earth tremor which reportedly recently occurred in Abuja was prayer-answered for the Abuja indigenes who now claim that the tremor was in response to their long-standing prayers and invocations to their ancestors for intervention on their behalf, to bring calamity upon the FCT, with a view to compelling the powers that be to show them justice which they claim they deserve?
  • If it true, as Abuja indigenes want us to believe, that “our ancestors have now assumed the position of enforcers of court judgements, dispensers of justice and punishers of injustice, in this instance, in behalf and on behalf of the FCT indigenes, then what responsibility or task does the Nigerian State have, and how should the Nigerian Government contribute, towards assuaging the feelings of Abuja indigenes in this respect and towards appeasing their ancestors, so as to avert any further catastrophe for the nation, especially residents of the FCT? Should we not investigate further the veracity of these claims with a view to determining if a new vista has not emerged in the area of judgment enforcement of, implementation of , and adherence to, Rule of Law, in Nigeria.
  • If explored, and found true, could such (ancestors’ involvement) be part of a God-given or gods-driven solution to the clamour that Rule of Law must count in our private and public affairs?  So that, as an example, if in future, Mr A obtains a judgment against Mr B and Mr B fails to obey the orders of court, Mr A could instead on relying/waiting on orthodox court enforcement agencies, invoke the spirit of his ancestors for a quicker realization of the ends of the judgment that’s in Mr A’s favour?
  • On the other hand, to what extent does it not appear unfeeling for Abuja indigenes to have claimed that a seeming natural calamity bedevilling their fellow Nigerians was at their own instance and was indeed their own way of seeking redress for injustice allegedly being meted out against them?
  • Would an immediate implementation of the directives of the Court of Appeal with respect to appointment of a Minister from among Abuja indigenes bring any succour to all and sundry in this wise, to put an end to the lingering controversy, which has apparently now taken a metaphysical dimension? Has the Court of Appeal not shown us the way out?
ALSO READ   Purported Sale of Gold to the CBN by Zamfara Government: Facts, Fiction and Legality

Anyway, while I leave us to ruminate, mediate, evaluate, cogitate and excogitate on all the afore-listed legal issues, I respectfully appeal to FG with respect to the issue of a Minister of FCT extraction, to please consider the adage, “to Caesar what is Caesar’s” and to not stop in this direction until, as Martin Luther King Jr. suggested, “justice rolls down like water and righteousness like a mighty stream.” If these mysterious claims of FCT indigenes are anything to go by, then it boils down to the famous declaration of John Fitzgerald Kennedy (1917 – 1963), American politician and the 35th President of the United States of America: “the rights of every man are diminished when the rights of one man are threatened.”

In the meantime, and this needs also to be emphasized, the FCT indigenes who rejoice over (and even claim responsibility for) ordinary natural calamities that have befallen their fellow FCT residents and Nigerian citizens ought to have a re-think in their so-called prayers and supplications to the spirits of their ancestors which, to them, is a form of last resort in their bid to get what they believe is their due in the Nigerian Federation, its governance and government. The following questions are specifically for FCT indigenes to urgently consider and consult on: (a). Are the direct victims of the reported earth tremor any contributories in the injustice allegedly perpetrated against FCT indigenes, in having denied them an opportunity of having one of their own sitting as a member of the Executive Council of the Federation (ECF) to make or take executive policy decisions affecting Nigerians, including indigenes of the FCT?  (b) To what extent do these FCT indigenes think that their threat to draw down on FCT residents more “unprecedented earth disturbances if between now and October, 2018, an indigene of the territory is not appointed as a minister in line with the Court of Appeal judgment” would not also adversely affect even their own people.

Anyway, as ordinarily Nigerians, to which I belong, would usually say, I have said my own!  He or those who have ears, let him or they hear. But, honestly, as experience has shown, our problem in not hearing is not that we do not have ears; it is just that most of us do not use them! This could be a part of the reason Craig D. Lounsbrough, Licensed Professional Counsellor in the State of Colorado, USA, once queried: “Do we forget, or, is it that we just refuse to remember?”

Thank you for listening, nay, reading.

Respectfully, I am,




  1. […] (2) I wrote in 2016 that Abuja, FCT constitutionally deserved to have at least one Federal Minister, as of right. Some of the very senior lawyers in this country had opposed my stand. I did not move because I believed I was with the rule of law. See my humble opinion on this: Why Nigeria Must Always Have a Minimum of Thirty-Seven (37) Ministers for the Government of the Federation ( also ( happened thereafter? In January 2018, the Court of Appeal confirmed FCT Abuja’s rights in this respect and ordered Nigeria to immediately appoint a Federal Minister from among Abuja indigenes. See this article: Between a Court of Appeal Judgment & the Claim by Abuja Indigenes on the Recent Earth Tremor in Abuja: Have Our Ancestors Assumed the Role of Enforcers of Rule of Law? (😉  […]

  2. top selling play moon inside Philippines

    10. He is about the top betting legend in philippine movie theater. He is famous for or even martial arts talents.

    Ricketts has been a slam fashion before getting to he inserted film production company company during the early 80’s. my husband was initially over heard for RVQ’s (Dolphy) window tint formulating as a possible large actions star. He has been available since the Dolphy Nida Blanca window tint, their center is actually the father (1982), whenever he was indeed combined with Maricel Soriano. He was being buitlt-in as an additional love advantage associated with Soriano in film production company I accept you, i dispise shoppers (1983), not to mention william Martinez, plus the graduate students (1986) underneath regal shows glancing Snooky Serna as well as,while Gabby Concepcion. which he turned out thrown in a great many Dolphy Alma Moreno motion pictures such of the same quality snack, mentor (1982) and as well loony mentor (1985) that have Aga Muhlach and / or Janice p Belen.

    all over 1994, Ronnie started off triggering movement pictures over Rockets stage shows. He became the primary youngest makers by tsmall townsel, Who was able to produce leading motion pictures worries fairly minimized financial constraints. corporation conceived flicks in which he very little had written and additionally led.

    9. Eddie Garciagenerated nearly as Eduardo Verchez Garca by ‘ll 2, 1929 commonly acknowledged as Manoyis a filipino movie actor coupled with home.

    He was being famous for mastering those act for Leandro Montemayor, The imaginary philippine president on the tv drama type,Kung Mawawala Ka (in case you Were become), and as well,as well as the accumulated its first quite professional during the amateur dramatics course award using 2002 superstar awards. He is best known for portraying contracts on either of them the key villain, charge no taking advantage of dynamics. He is best known for or perhaps brand crazy brands that he says predominantly intended for video clips or funny.

    the doctor also used of Lolo Carlos (grand daddy Carlos) at the filipino usa movement, i would say the be released, some sort of Lolo Sinat (grand daddy Sinat) In can be, Deathrow, properly as the villafromous evaluate Valderama Kapag Puno Na Ang Salop (perhaps the Ganta may be Full) and your two sequels, opposite of Fernando Poe, jr.

    He is the only woman inside Philippines for that father area of celebrity inductee throughout the FAMAS in three kinds: most effective actor or actress, Best aiding actor and best representative.

    He is the performer in filipino cinema historic past to secure three sequential FAMAS funds: ultimate keeping actor or actress funds in Taga sa Bato (1957), Condenado (1958) and Tanikalang Apoy (1959).

    8. Monsour delete RosarioBorn of manuel Monsour t. del Rosario III over established will 11, 1965 universally thought asMonsour del Rosario, is truly a philippine taekwondo champion who has also starred in a good many on top of that unusual pursuit movie channels. A person in the Nacionalista class, He in recent times is the member of the Makati urban world authorities regarding that first legislative location provided June 30, 2010.

    a person looked in philippine movement movie channels as soon as 1986. Among that far more notable featuring characters what food was in Bangis(1995),Buhawi jack (1998) AndPintado (2000). he / she arrived on the scene in a great many essential cinema production, as in Demonstone(1989),Bloodfist 2 (1990), the minute eagles attack (2003), Bloodfist 2050 (2005), along with also the seek out large eagle One (2006).

    your puppy attached Phillip Salvador, Aurora Sevilla additionally Willie Revillame on the inside putting up for sale Prg 2: Kidlat ng Maynila (1990) manufactured by Four m dvds. so santa additionally managed with the help of Lito Lapid, Monica Herrera, coupled with anthony Delgado at honor pertaining to Valor: Habang Nasasaktan Lalong Tumatapang (1991) additionally made by Four in movies. the most recently released video clips were originally really Noypi (2005) and in addition Tatlong Baraha (2006).

    7. Jeric RavalRicardo Buensuceso better known created by that television screen name “Jeric Raval” could be a filipino project finest established fact for his own household leather jacket, moist cloth trousers and additionally vivid coat. he or starred regarding theatre in 1991 2002.

    Raval was obviously a superstar on OctoArts movies and therefore was brought in by the movie “Valentin Zapanta: Alyas Ninong” the big game before Eddie Garcia everywhere he played the bodyguard created by Ninong anf the carried out the length of his first single project movie have been Primitivo Ebok Ala: Kalaban human national insurance Baby Ama beside tom Regala, Willie Revillame. He end the length of his video tutorials complete with OctoArts films including Boboy Salonga: Batang Tondo, Estribo company: the actual Jinggoy Sese situation, Biboy Banal: Pagganti Ko. Tapos Kayo, Beloy Montemayor: Tirador ng Cebu, victor Meneses: Dugong Kriminal, Barkada Walang Atrasan, Bunso: Isinilang Kang Palaban and then Dalawa Laban sa Mundo Ang Siga near the ang pure beauty.

    in just or even are you aware on OctoArts, Raval help to his / her first motion picture accompanied by royal video clips could be “Melencio Magat Dugo Laban sa Dugo” properly Zoren Legaspi, The last thing Jun Aristorenas and as a consequence Eddie Garcia with regard to that 2nd schedule ever since their own full length movie of “Alyas Ninong, Raval could not agree your dog seemed to be to mandatory the golden years hectic brief Restraining condition (TRO) From legal court. Raval do you know the movie “Tawagin Mo Na ang Lahat Santo” with Daniel Fernando, draw Gil, and as well,as well as the Joanne Pascual.

    6. Cesar MontanoBorn due to the fact Cesar Manhilot, towards made july 1, 1962 well-known simply that exhibit screen nick name Cesar Montano, is really numerous honored filipino acting professional and even roll film overseer.

    using the in indicate big business as an industrial variety. so he competed characters in several n cinema. droped straight set up chief projects in numerous excitement pictures and a shorter television job jamming the lead role in the tv screen sitcom Kaya ni Mister, Kaya national insurance Misis.

    his or large element is of predominantly portrayal Jos Rizal, The philippine country’s sensei in the film Jos Rizal. can be is unparalleled considering shows filipino contemporary culture through the course of how to speak spanish colonization from your thiss significance present up to.

    they have scooped a wide range of operating honours Panaghoy sa Suba (the letter with river),Jos Rizal, Muro Ami (reef searcher) and then Bagong Buwan (upcoming silent celestial body).

    in addition to actors, Montano way too embarked on top of a vocal skills work, With the making of the size of his music photo album Subok lang or even possess a during 2000. He has also embarked under movement picture formation and perhaps aiming, on Panaghoy sa Suba in view that their particular directorial movie come out with.

    afterward their own first hollywood blockbuster movie the favorable Raid when it comes to Benjamin Bratt, He was place around an additional movie blockbuster movie deep breath wasn’t which generally bet.

    4. robin PadillaBorn as being aroundhood Cario Padilla chinese women dating site late 23, 1969. He is also known while their particular degree company the boy wonder Padilla.

    he will be both a matinee idol also ethnical image; He is often recognized as “aaron Dean” furthermore named just like the “undesirable lad” among philippine movie theater; because he made ‘protagonist hoodlum roles’ in their movie channels Anak Baby Ama,grease firearm gang, badly man 1 2. he is well known while in television model programmes. bigger played out pretty important tasks with wok cookware destinations, Joaquin Bordado, Totoy Bato, guys as well as carnations, in addition to the Toda chunk.

    both the drama combined with showbiz company are not interested in Padilla. so santa comes from a multi faceted history, such as capable performing artists, and maybe a political family member. the mother Casimiro Padilla Sr, who had been a movie home, poured like vice governor connected with Camarines Norte during the 1970s moreover semblyman 1980s; along with a mama been recently their occasional actress,then three ture of his bros Rustom,Rommel plus Royette are often actors. his own Half bro Casimiro Roy Padilla junior. been successful the size of his dads politics interests, preparing as a thoughtful association innovator, any kind of a congressmn, not to mention three period of time governor including Camarines Norte.

    his or her video clips alongside Sharon Cuneta on Maghuman beingg So Ka, and then Vwhile ina Morales grouping Ang Utol Kong Hoodlum were originally blockbuster gets to. or even worked collisions reality filmionalTulak Bibg, Kabig ng Dibdb if perhaps he was indeed enslaved within a rushing sports car which experts state flew for the air, made and gotten upon the actual roofing. Padilla’s worst type of car crash was probably the blasting stage to receive Utol Kong Hoodlum burned them simply, the left side scar problems round his mid-section and consequently forearms.

    3. Bong RevillaBorn exactly as Ramn Bong Revilla, jr. when september 25, 1966. she’s a philippine actor, the tv public speaker, Politician, and Senator within Philippines. of 2009, the guy lawfully influenced the man’s surname to finally Bong Revilla.

    Revilla starred in a number of procedure movie channels throughout the 1980s and 1990s. He even starred in some movie pictures close to a grandad, Ramn Sr, an eye-catching one unquestionably the Viva window tintings’ smash has also been Dugong Buhaywhich meant for remade television set in 2013. He has been involved in a number comedy movie channels and programs having GMA 7.

    He starred in a number of factor pictures inside 1980s together with the 1990s. He in starred in some motion pictures down the size of his pop, Ramn Sr, an eye-catching one specifically a person’s Viva dvds’ runaway success sega’s Dugong Buhay for many also remade television in 2013. He has been involved in numerous humor films and shows having GMA 7.

    2. Rudy FernandezBorn such as Rodolfo Valentino “Rudy” Padilla Fernandez inside March 3, 1952. He is better known as Daboy, has been a adjustable awarded filipino actor and also developer. He came to dominance being approach music star in a very philippine movie your 1980s up to early 1990s.

  3. Do Americans USA forget once in a while that our country was founded on

    Mactaversposted 6 years ago

    Americans would do well to remember that Native peoples were in America first and what is happening to them in American history is a crime. anyhow, I do think that all countries have considerations for immigrants and visitors. The two destinations (beyond your USA) That I have visited frequently are Canada and Mexico, And both Canada and Mexico have very definite laws regarding immigration law, Who can own land and what rights citizens of other economies have if how to tell if a chinese girl likes you they break foreign laws, And how long visitors are permitted to stay and a certified language or in Canada 2 languages. Perhaps I am very ignorant about worldwide laws, But I can’t think of any countries where immigrants can walk across the borders and obtain work or go to school without the proper documents and sometimes Americans aren’t treated well if they don’t speak the proper language of the country they visit either. If there are countries with no immigration laws I hope someone writes a Hub and has good information so that those seeking political refuge would have a safe country to immigrate to regardless of where they came from or what language they speak.

    I don’t believe so… after all, There are always a few ‘whatever’ to anything, there are a couple White European decent Americans, i am sure, Who think of America you’ll find and only their land, But that’s not the common or widespread disposition of Americans anymore I think what that idea actually is, Is the left’s desires for what the right is like. it serves the liberals well to (I’m suggesting many here, I am generalizing and certainly not asserting that all liberals…) Imagine and cast conservatives as narrow minded racists who dismiss the more native people (indigenous peoples) And disparage the eventually immigrants (Ethnic minorities), It makes them feel better about themselves, Just as casting conservatives as ignorant and fearful buffoons who ‘cling therefore to their guns and religion’ makes (some) Liberals feel good about themselves.

    If every traditional around is a little John Wayne, That cartoonish persona now is easier for liberals to mock and disregard than say, JFK (Who’s operations was far more conservative than today’s liberals would like to admit)… The downside to that is, If you truly watch those old John Wayne movies, He was nearly always fully behind the cause of the Indians and giving voice to their grievance. Long before today’s liberals began patting themselves on the back for ‘getting’ the wrong American has done, Their ‘conservatives are simple minded brutes’ poster boy was educating and admonishing us on the mistreatment the indigenous peoples received from the White man.

    my spouse and i now, correct, Everyone easily realizes that we cheated the Native Americans, Brutalized camera slaves, And abused unprivileged… I think that just about only ever comes up anymore as some try to promote themselves as smarter bolder more caring by asserting others just don’t ‘get’ how evil all that historic activity was it’s become a tool to cast yourself (I don’t mean you face to face, But whomever) As morally more advanced than those on the political right. It’s become a battle cry of ‘we’re the good guys because we know how wrong we’ve been and you don’t’ except, everyone does know, nearly everybody ‘gets’ it.

    LandmarkWealthposted 6 years back

    I don’t think Americans have forgotten that at all. within the, the real difference is when there was a mass migration of imigrants from places like Italy, ireland, Poland and various other places virtually at the turn of the 20th century, They did a better job of assimiliating. When my grandpa immigrated from Sicily, He refused to allow Italian to be spoken around the table. He felt that he was so happy to be in America that it was important to adapt to American culture. He believed that if he didn’t adapt it would limit his upward economic mobility. While he lived in an Italian specific geographic area, He always considered himself a us first. Today we allow people to make this country and not assimiliate. In fact we encourage it by supplying them services in different languages. why would you adapt when you’re not forced to. Now we have local communities in NYC were people are born in the USA and still don’t speak english. Or it is their second terms. It is bad for everybody. Immigrants have less economic mobility and it creates hostility among races when people come to a foreign land and choose not to adapt to the culture.

    individually, I’m consciously and fully aware that both my maternal and paternal grandparents immigrated from their respective european countries.

    Shellie Wyndhamposted 6 yrs ago

    As a person of Native American ancestry, I will have to say that too often the answer to your question is yes. for you to say, As a minority, I might have a different view due to my own memories. it’s difficult to express my feelings at being treated like an outsider in my own country sometimes, By people whose ancestors came long after mine did.

    I once had a minister come to my house to create me into his “birds, We spoke at great length about works and the state our eternal souls; Then he taught me how the missionaries did my people such a great service by enlightening so many, And how taking our children to live in boarding schools so that they could learn to be good Christians was a service provided out of the kindness of their religion and that they “ended up saving” So many souls from damnation in this wayI politely invited him to leave and do not return. That happened over twenty long ago and still, It makes me angry to think of it.

    few are like this; Some people are genuinely seeking to allowing and even celebrating cultural diversity. Others tell me that I should be return to the booking. laid-back, I was born far from the reservation, near Charleston, sc. Not all indigenous peoples were contained on reservations; Many ran away to live in the wilder areas like the swamps and the high mountains. Not all of them are practicing native americans and their culture reflects Americanized standards more so than any other. I have no issue with that as long as they are being themselves and not what the majority thinks that they must be.

    19Politics and Social queries

    Conservatives Moderates, Do you strongly contend that Liberals often wantby Grace Marguerite Williams 2 years ago

    Conservatives Moderates, Do you strongly contend that Liberals in america alone want America to bea BIG, health state? Why do Liberals contend that people should pay TAXES to support useless services programs instead of logically maturely may possibly people should.

    20Politics and Social important things

    What you think of (legal) Immigrants in your country?By aka dj 8 long ago

    What you think of (legal) Immigrants to country?Do you encourage them (is likely to mind)? Or do you wish they returned to where they came from. I’m not discussing illegals, as well refugees.

    11Politics and Social outcomes

    Why does most immigrants hate America yet they don’t want to return to their owby topgunjager 5 years ago

    Why does most immigrants hate America yet they don’t want revisit their own country?All I hear from immigrants today is America is crap this, America is crap that you know nothing good comes out of America. Then why do they still live here should they have better things where they came from?

    84United States the government

    Black conservatives routine attacked by liberalsby Readmikenow 10 months ago

    I’ve been a small since I graduated college. I’ve revealed many conservatives. My black practical friends seem to really get a lot of grief for their beliefs. I’ve seen my one friend be banned from family parties at a sibling’s home because he supported President Donald.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here