HomeNewsA Justice System Under Kidnap: When Judges Can’t Come to Court and...

A Justice System Under Kidnap: When Judges Can’t Come to Court and the Bench Lies Broken in Nsukka

Date:

For several years now, a quiet tragedy has been unfolding in the Nsukka Senatorial Zone of Enugu State. It is not the kind that grabs national headlines or triggers emergency interventions. It is slow, corrosive, and largely invisible, yet it is dismantling one of the most fundamental pillars of democracy: access to justice.

Reports from lawyers practising within the zone paint a disturbing picture. Nearly all judges and magistrates assigned to Nsukka, Igbo-Eze, Udenu, Isi-Uzo, Igbo-Etiti and surrounding divisions have stopped sitting physically due to the high level of insecurity along the Ugwogo—Nsukka—Opi axis. Judicial officers have been kidnapped, ambushed, or have narrowly escaped with their lives. After a series of attacks in 2022 and 2023, the courts simply shut their doors.

In place of physical sittings, virtual hearings were adopted. But what was intended as a technological bridge has become a trap, an inadequate, uneven, and often dysfunctional substitute that has left litigants stranded, lawyers frustrated, and justice effectively suspended.

From Courts to Cobwebs: How Nsukka Judicial Divisions Went Dark

Following repeated kidnappings of magistrates, lawyers, and court staff, judicial officers abandoned their posts and relocated to the Enugu State Judiciary Headquarters. Courtrooms in Nsukka and neighbouring divisions became ghost chambers, deserted buildings now occupied by lizards, cockroaches, and rodents.

Filings were reduced to one day a week, and only if the ACR was brave enough to risk the dangerous road.

When lawyers protested and even seized registrars’ phones to demonstrate their frustration, the Chief Judge issued a directive: judges should return “if they can” or else use “adequate” virtual hearing equipment. The reality was that no such equipment existed.

Thus, virtual courts became synonymous with:

  • registrars’ mobile phones as court microphones,
  • unstable network connections,
  • endless adjournments,
  • litigants who did not believe justice had taken place unless they saw the court physically,
  • and a justice system held together by improvisation and hope.

Hon. Justice Alukwu was widely regarded as the only judge who, for nearly four years, braved the insecurity to physically traverse that difficult route. Her courage earned the admiration of many Nsukka-based lawyers, who credited her presence with restoring confidence in the justice system. Her consistent physical sittings revived activities at the Nsukka High Court, until her eventual transfer. Since her departure, however, hearings have dwindled once more, now occurring only about once a week and almost always virtually.

January, 2024 when Lawyers protested non-appearance of judges at Nsukka high courts

Virtual Hearings Without Virtual Capacity: A System Designed to Fail

The Enugu State High Court Rules (Order 58) permit virtual hearings where practicable, dependent on available tools and network connectivity. But in Nsukka Senatorial Zone, “practicable” is a distant ideal, far removed from the current reality. Lawyers practising in the area describe a litany of recurring challenges that render virtual hearings largely ineffective.

Chronic network failures frequently disrupt proceedings: judges freeze mid-sentence, witnesses disappear from screens, and audio cuts out. These interruptions leave hearings fragmented, incoherent, and often unusable. Power failures compound the problem, with virtual sessions collapsing whenever electricity falters; a common occurrence.

Court ethics and decorum are also compromised. Participants join from random locations, sometimes in pyjamas or nightwear, while prosecutors have been observed leading IPOs from motor parks. Witnesses may switch off cameras or receive off-screen coaching, and litigants often sit in lawyers’ offices while counsel quietly provides answers during cross-examination. Such conditions undermine the integrity of the judicial process.

Judges, moreover, are unable to fully assess credibility. Body language, facial expressions, hesitation, and other subtle cues are often lost on camera, making cases dependent on witness credibility particularly vulnerable. Compounding this, many judges, court staff, and litigants struggle with basic digital literacy, including sending emails, uploading documents, and navigating virtual platforms.

Hardware deficiencies further weaken the system. Most courts in the zone lack essential equipment such as TV screens, cameras, microphones, stable internet connections, and proper recording systems. Evidence management is chaotic: tendering certified true copies or originals often results in blurred images, unreadable scans, or unverifiable documents, leading to chronic miscarriages of justice.

Digital security is another concern. Weak controls leave court recordings, witness interviews, and sensitive criminal evidence exposed to hacking, unauthorized access, and tampering. Meanwhile, litigants’ confidence in the system has collapsed. Many do not understand virtual hearings, distrust the process, doubt judgments, and feel deceived when they cannot physically “see the court.” In some cases, litigants cannot even identify the judge on screen, as everyone appears robed identically.

In short, the promise of virtual justice in Nsukka has become a system designed to fail, leaving lawyers, litigants, and the courts themselves trapped in an unworkable and often unjust process.

The Human Cost: When Justice Goes Dark

When courts become inaccessible, the consequences are devastating and far-reaching. Litigants, unable to seek lawful remedies, now resort to self-help. Disputes that should be resolved through formal legal processes are taken to native doctors, vigilante groups, and even criminal elements. Hoodlums are hired to intimidate, assault, and in some cases, kill. It is a dangerous slide back into pre-state methods of conflict resolution.

Defendants awaiting trial are not spared. Many remain in detention indefinitely; their cases stalled with no end in sight. They are left to languish in custodial centres, effectively punished without conviction.

Lawyers, too, bear a heavy burden. Their professional lives are steadily eroding under the weight of missed hearings, wasted travel, and erratic court schedules. Income suffers, practice becomes unpredictable, and career growth is stifled.

Worst of all, entire communities begin to lose faith in the justice system. When state institutions retreat, insecurity festers, and the very foundations of democracy weaken. The darkness in the courts quickly becomes a darkness in society itself.

The Most Troubling Part: A Conspiracy of Silence

Perhaps the most troubling aspect of the Nsukka crisis is the quiet indifference of those who ought to act. The State Government has failed to prioritise judicial access in the area, while security agencies have yet to restore safe passage to the courts. The judiciary’s leadership continues to offer half-measures that do little to change the reality on ground. Civil society organisations have not mounted the sustained pressure such a collapse of justice demands, and the local Bar, limited in structural power cannot compel action on its own.

This collective silence only deepens the crisis. Justice dies fastest in quiet places.

Practical Measures to Revive the Nsukka Judiciary

The crisis is grave, but it is not beyond repair. What is needed is not political combativeness, but political will and institutional sincerity. The following steps are realistic, implementable, and essential.

  1. Restore Security Along the Ugwogo–Nsukka–Opi Corridor (Immediate Priority)

The first and most urgent task is to make the Ugwogo–Nsukka–Opi corridor safe again. This requires deploying joint security task forces, activating community intelligence networks, and installing surveillance cameras and strategic checkpoints. Rapid response units must be stationed along the route to deter attacks and intervene quickly. Judicial officers must be able to travel safely to court; anything less is unconstitutional.

Construct Judges’ Residents in Nsukka

One potent solution is to urgently construct Judge’s Quarters in Nsukka Senatorial Zone in safe areas of the town with adequate security provided. The judges and magistrates would not have to traverse the trouble spot to get to their courts to perform their duties if they live among the people and have their court rooms close by.

Let this issue be escalated to the National Body of the NBA to come to our aid even if it is inside the University environment

  • Install Functional Virtual Courtrooms in Every Affected Division

Every affected court must immediately be equipped with functional virtual hearing infrastructure: HD cameras, smart screens, microphones, reliable broadband, backup power, and secure digital platforms for receiving and reviewing evidence. Virtual justice cannot depend on a registrar’s mobile phone; it requires proper tools and professional standards. If the courts have to sit virtually, the court rooms should be well equipped and lawyers should be in the courtroom if the judge has to be away for any reason.

  • Introduce Digital Training for Judges, Lawyers, And Court Staff

To support a more resilient judicial system, training and retraining in digital tools is essential. The judiciary should collaborate with NBA branches, ICT professionals, and digital rights organisations to equip judges, lawyers, and court staff in Enugu state and particularly in Nsukka with skills in cybersecurity, virtual evidence management, email and document handling, online ethics, and digital courtroom decorum.

  • Establish Strict Virtual Court Protocols

Virtual proceedings require uniform standards to maintain dignity and order. These should include proper dress codes, rules for camera positioning, sanctions for improper conduct, and mandatory video participation except in exceptional circumstances. These protocols will reinforce respect for the process and the institution.

  • Prioritise Custodial Cases Through Special Sessions

Defendants awaiting trial must not be punished by insecurity. Special weekly sessions, whether virtual or physical, should be dedicated specifically to custodial cases. This ensures that those deprived of their liberty are not also deprived of justice.

  • Improve Digital Evidence Systems

A modern justice system requires modern evidence handling. Secure cloud storage, encrypted file-sharing systems, digital chain-of-custody logs, and standardised document formats must be adopted to ensure integrity, accessibility, and efficiency in managing digital evidence.

  • Create A Multi-Stakeholder Accountability Forum

Finally, a joint accountability framework is necessary to break the present silence. A multi-stakeholder forum, bringing together the judiciary, NBA, civil society, law enforcement, and community leaders, should provide public, periodic reports on security improvements, functioning courts, case backlogs cleared, and virtual system upgrades. Transparency will restore trust and drive reform.

JUSTICE CANNOT BE A CASUALTY OF INSECURITY

In conclusion, the situation in Nsukka is more than a local inconvenience.
It is a constitutional breach, a humanitarian concern, and a governance failure.

When courts shut down, insecurity wins. When virtual justice collapses, fairness collapses with it. When litigants turn to native doctors and vigilantes, the state loses moral and legal authority. When defendants languish without trial, our constitutional promises ring hollow.

But this crisis can still be reversed if stakeholders stop pretending it does not exist. The people of Nsukka deserve better. The judiciary deserves protection. Lawyers deserve functional courts.

And justice, real justice deserves a chance to breathe again.

Share on
PLACE YOUR ADVERT HERE

Related articles:

US Court Sentences Ex-Police Officer to 40 Years in Prison for Sexually Assaulting 14-Year-Old Girl

A former Nigerian-American police officer in the United States,...

THE LEGALITY OF NO-REFUND POLICIES IN NIGERIA: EXAMINING CONSUMER RIGHTS AND THE LIMITS OF COMMERCIAL FREEDOM UNDER THE FCCPA 2018

  By: ONYINYECHUKWU UMEH Esq. 1. Introduction When you walk into a...