By Emem Ekpenyong
FRN v KANU (2023) LPELR – 79929 (SC) Part 4
The SC faulted the manner Mazi was shipped into this country, but nonetheless held that the decision of the CA striking out the retained charges was not rooted in law. The SC ordered Mazi to MARCH to the FHC and answer the charges against him. Read for yourself, so that you will not be misled by mischief makers.
ISSUE – WHETHER AN ILLEGAL ABDUCTION/EXTRAORDINARY RENDITION OF AN ACCUSED PERSON FROM ANOTHER COUNTRY CAN INVALIDATE A PENDING CRIMINAL TRIAL OR DEPRIVE THE NIGERIAN COURT OF JURISDICTION TO TRY THE ACCUSED
“…This far-reaching decision of the lower Court triggered serious discourse, particularly on whether an extraordinary rendition of a person will have the consequence of rendering the entire charge against him null and void. Courts are creations of statutes, and they are created along with their jurisdiction and powers as conferred on them by the enabling statute, such statutory jurisdiction can only be taken away by another statutory enactment, in other words statutory jurisdiction cannot be taken away by mere omission to follow due process in securing the attendance in Court by an accused person to answer the charge against him. The Federal High Court is richly vested with jurisdiction in civil and criminal cases by the provisions of Section 251(1)(a) to (r) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (as amended). The Terrorism Prevention Act 2011 as amended by the Terrorism Prevention Act, 2013 confers exclusive jurisdiction on the Federal High Court to hear and determine terrorism cases.
It would be simplistic and contrary to law to insist that such powers and jurisdiction as entrenched in the Constitution and Acts of the National Assembly can be rendered barren and sterile for reasons of extra ordinary rendition of a fugitive. The provisions of Section 251 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, (as amended), and Section 32 of the Terrorism Prevention Act, 2011 as amended by the Terrorism Prevention (Amendment) Act 2013 are still valid and subsisting, they are part of our laws vesting jurisdiction on the trial Court, the provisions cannot be rendered void by mere reason of irregular and extraordinary rendition of the escapee Respondent. I therefore dare say that the charge against the Respondent was initiated by due process, the trial Court therefore had jurisdiction to try the Respondent. See MADUKOLU V. NKEMDILIM (1962) SCNLR 341. THE LOWER COURT FELL INTO AN IRREDEEMABLY GRAVE ERROR OF JUDGMENT TO HAVE QUASHED THE CHARGE AGAINST THE RESPONDENT.
I would like to refer to the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organised crimes, (The Palermo Convention) in particular the United Nations General Assembly resolution 55/25 which states in part as follows: “Strongly convinced that the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime will constitute an effective tool and the necessary legal framework for international cooperation in combating, inter alia, such criminal activities as money-laundering, corruption, illicit trafficking in endangered species of wild flora and fauna, offences against cultural heritage and the growing links between transnational organized crime and terrorist crimes,” Article 21 of the convention which provides as follows: Article 21 “Transfer of criminal proceedings States Parties shall consider the possibility of transferring to one another proceedings for the prosecution of an offence covered by this Convention in cases where such transfer is considered to be in the interests of the proper administration of justice, in particular in cases where several jurisdictions are involved, with a view to concentrating the prosecution.” Nigeria is a state party to the convention and the Convention made elaborate provisions for International cooperation in combatting the offences listed in the convention and interestingly enough, Nigeria has already gone ahead to have domestic legislation in line with the General Assembly resolution and articles of the Convention.
Nigeria has an obligation under the convention to comply with the articles and seek mutual legal assistance through the central authority in Kenya or ask for extradition in line with the law. The state as the guardian of the public must not engage in reckless and brazen exercise of power. The state does not loose anything if due process is followed in securing the extradition of the fugitive through proper and established extradition process established by law. Our domestic Extradition Act and the Convention provide for robust extradition process and transfer of criminal proceedings, why not exploit, or take advantage of this simple and seamless process, the conduct of the Federal Government in bundling the Respondent out of Kenya without due process is unimpressive and there is need for those responsible for guiding the conscience of the Government to take responsibility and act right. The Respondent knows where his remedies lie. THE DECISION OF THE LOWER COURT THROWING AWAY THE ENTIRE CHARGE IS OBVIOUSLY WRONG BECAUSE IT IS NEITHER NECESSARY NOR PREMISED ON ANY LAW, IT IS THEREFORE GROSSLY LACKING IN SEMBLANCE OF LEGAL JUSTIFICATION AND MUST THEREFORE BE SET ASIDE. THE RESPONDENT MUST THEREFORE MARCH TO THE TRIAL COURT AND ANSWER THE CHARGE AGAINST HIM.”
Per TIJJANI ABUBAKAR ,JSCFRN v KANU (2023) LPELR – 79929 (SC) Part 4
The SC faulted the manner Mazi was shipped into this country, but nonetheless held that the decision of the CA striking out the retained charges was not rooted in law. The SC ordered Mazi to MARCH to the FHC and answer the charges against him. Read for yourself, so that you will not be misled by mischief makers.
ISSUE – WHETHER AN ILLEGAL ABDUCTION/EXTRAORDINARY RENDITION OF AN ACCUSED PERSON FROM ANOTHER COUNTRY CAN INVALIDATE A PENDING CRIMINAL TRIAL OR DEPRIVE THE NIGERIAN COURT OF JURISDICTION TO TRY THE ACCUSED
“…This far-reaching decision of the lower Court triggered serious discourse, particularly on whether an extraordinary rendition of a person will have the consequence of rendering the entire charge against him null and void. Courts are creations of statutes, and they are created along with their jurisdiction and powers as conferred on them by the enabling statute, such statutory jurisdiction can only be taken away by another statutory enactment, in other words statutory jurisdiction cannot be taken away by mere omission to follow due process in securing the attendance in Court by an accused person to answer the charge against him. The Federal High Court is richly vested with jurisdiction in civil and criminal cases by the provisions of Section 251(1)(a) to (r) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (as amended). The Terrorism Prevention Act 2011 as amended by the Terrorism Prevention Act, 2013 confers exclusive jurisdiction on the Federal High Court to hear and determine terrorism cases.
It would be simplistic and contrary to law to insist that such powers and jurisdiction as entrenched in the Constitution and Acts of the National Assembly can be rendered barren and sterile for reasons of extra ordinary rendition of a fugitive. The provisions of Section 251 of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, (as amended), and Section 32 of the Terrorism Prevention Act, 2011 as amended by the Terrorism Prevention (Amendment) Act 2013 are still valid and subsisting, they are part of our laws vesting jurisdiction on the trial Court, the provisions cannot be rendered void by mere reason of irregular and extraordinary rendition of the escapee Respondent. I therefore dare say that the charge against the Respondent was initiated by due process, the trial Court therefore had jurisdiction to try the Respondent. See MADUKOLU V. NKEMDILIM (1962) SCNLR 341. THE LOWER COURT FELL INTO AN IRREDEEMABLY GRAVE ERROR OF JUDGMENT TO HAVE QUASHED THE CHARGE AGAINST THE RESPONDENT.
I would like to refer to the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organised crimes, (The Palermo Convention) in particular the United Nations General Assembly resolution 55/25 which states in part as follows: “Strongly convinced that the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime will constitute an effective tool and the necessary legal framework for international cooperation in combating, inter alia, such criminal activities as money-laundering, corruption, illicit trafficking in endangered species of wild flora and fauna, offences against cultural heritage and the growing links between transnational organized crime and terrorist crimes,” Article 21 of the convention which provides as follows: Article 21 “Transfer of criminal proceedings States Parties shall consider the possibility of transferring to one another proceedings for the prosecution of an offence covered by this Convention in cases where such transfer is considered to be in the interests of the proper administration of justice, in particular in cases where several jurisdictions are involved, with a view to concentrating the prosecution.” Nigeria is a state party to the convention and the Convention made elaborate provisions for International cooperation in combatting the offences listed in the convention and interestingly enough, Nigeria has already gone ahead to have domestic legislation in line with the General Assembly resolution and articles of the Convention.
Nigeria has an obligation under the convention to comply with the articles and seek mutual legal assistance through the central authority in Kenya or ask for extradition in line with the law. The state as the guardian of the public must not engage in reckless and brazen exercise of power. The state does not loose anything if due process is followed in securing the extradition of the fugitive through proper and established extradition process established by law. Our domestic Extradition Act and the Convention provide for robust extradition process and transfer of criminal proceedings, why not exploit, or take advantage of this simple and seamless process, the conduct of the Federal Government in bundling the Respondent out of Kenya without due process is unimpressive and there is need for those responsible for guiding the conscience of the Government to take responsibility and act right. The Respondent knows where his remedies lie. THE DECISION OF THE LOWER COURT THROWING AWAY THE ENTIRE CHARGE IS OBVIOUSLY WRONG BECAUSE IT IS NEITHER NECESSARY NOR PREMISED ON ANY LAW, IT IS THEREFORE GROSSLY LACKING IN SEMBLANCE OF LEGAL JUSTIFICATION AND MUST THEREFORE BE SET ASIDE. THE RESPONDENT MUST THEREFORE MARCH TO THE TRIAL COURT AND ANSWER THE CHARGE AGAINST HIM.”
Per TIJJANI ABUBAKAR ,JSC
