By Emem Ekpenyong
FRN v KANU (2023) LPELR – 79929 (SC) – Part 10
I have attempted to counter falsehood with facts. I intentionally refused to summarize the holdings. I wanted my readers to read and decide which version of the alleged SC’s judgement to believe. I gave full citation for ease of reference. A judge should not live in fear because legal consultants are out to create content and gain visibility via this case. The SC did not at any point strip the FHC of jurisdiction to try the matter because Mazi was illegally extradited from Kenya. The SC held that while Nigeria must comply with Treaties which it is a signatory, where weighty allegation of crimes affecting national security or public safety is involved, Treaties will take the backseat, while national security would be prioritized.
“Before I end this judgment, I would mention and acknowledge that there is an International bilateral obligation on all nations of the world that are members of the United Nations Organization and such other Continental or Regional Bodies, to honour and comply with all Treaties, Agreements, Conventions, e.t.c, to which they are signatories and/or which they domesticate in their bilateral relationships with one another, but when very serious and weighty allegations of crimes or offences affecting the general national security, well-being, public safety and corporate existence of Nigeria are made or involved, they take priority and precedence over such Treaties, conventions, e.t.c., which should not be used to shield accused persons from the law and justice.
In that regard, I endorse the caution sounded in the case of Dokubo-Asari v. FRN (supra) , re-echoed recently in the case of Aminu Sadiq Ogwuche v. FRN & 4 Ors (2021) 6 NWLR (pt. 1775) 540 at 556 (SC) which the Appellant therein, along with others, was charged with terrorism under the 2013 Act (like the Respondent vin this appeal). In the lead judgment, Hon. Justice J. I. Okoro, JSC had stated at paragraphs E – F, that: It has to be noted that where national security is threatened or there is real likely hood of its being threatened, the Court must be circumspect in handing issues of human rights of persons standing trial in such cases. See Asari-Dokubo v. FRN (2009) 37 (2) NSCQR, 1114 at 1184, (2007) 12 NWLR (pt. 1048) 320.”
In the final result, I find merit in this appeal and allow it.”
PER MOHAMMED LAWAL GARBA, JSC
After reading through the case, I checked for a certain detail, which I will not disclose. Legal consultants should earn their fee. If the prosecution did not cross its T on that particular detail, on appeal, if legal consultants can identify that loophole, the appellate court may order for a re-trial. The operative word being ‘MAY’. However, I await the CTC of the judgement delivered on the 20th. The judgement will provide more insight on that particular T and if it was properly crossed.
