HomeNewsUntangling FRN v. Kanu: What the Supreme Court Really Decided — Part...

Untangling FRN v. Kanu: What the Supreme Court Really Decided — Part 7

Date:

By Emem Ekpenyong

FRN v KANU (2023) LPELR – 79929 (SC) Part 7

After condemning the manner Mazi was illegally extradited from Kenya, the SC went ahead to hold that where an accused’s fundamental right has been violated by law enforcement agents, he has a right to remedies for such violation in a civil suit, but the violation of his right will not invalidate the charges against him.

ISSUE – WHETHER AN ILLEGAL ABDUCTION/EXTRAORDINARY RENDITION OF AN ACCUSED PERSON FROM ANOTHER COUNTRY CAN INVALIDATE A PENDING CRIMINAL TRIAL OR DEPRIVE THE NIGERIAN COURT OF JURISDICTION TO TRY THE ACCUSED

“The question to be determined here is whether this Appellant’s brazen lawlessness, the illegal, unfair and oppressive treatment of the Respondent for the purpose of bringing him from Kenya to Court for trial in the criminal case pending against him in Nigeria should render the pending criminal case invalid, an abuse of process and divest the Court of the jurisdiction to try him in that case. In Nigeria, EXCEPT STATUTORY AND CONSTITUTIONAL PRESCRIPTIONS AGAINST SELF INCRIMINATION, THERE IS NO STATUTE PRESCRIBING SUCH CONSEQUENCE.

The established case law through the cases is that even though a strict adherence to statutory prescriptions concerning pre-trial criminal processes and the processes for bringing the accused to Court for trial is a sine qua non for a fair trial process, VIOLATIONS OF THE FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS OF AN ACCUSED AND OTHER UNLAWFUL ACTIONS BY THE PROSECUTION AT THE PRE-TRIAL STAGE GIVE THE ACCUSED A RIGHT OF ACTION FOR REMEDIES FOR VIOLATIONS OF HIS FUNDAMENTAL RIGHT AND OTHER CIVIL REMEDIES AND HAVE NO EFFECT ON THE VALIDITY OF THE WHOLE CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS AGAINST HIM AND THE JURISDICTION OF THE COURT TO ENTERTAIN THE PROCEEDINGS AND TRY HIM, PROVIDED THE FACTS ALLEGED AGAINST HIM DISCLOSE AN OFFENCE CREATED BY WRITTEN LAW AND A REASONABLE BASIS FOR SUSPECTING HE COMMITTED THAT OFFENCE.

So THE ESTABLISHED CASE LAW IN NIGERIA IS THAT VIOLATIONS OF THE FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS OF AN ACCUSED AND ANY ILLEGALITY IN PRE-TRIAL OR EXTRAJUDICIAL PROCESSES IN RELATION TO AN ACCUSED SHOULD NOT AFFECT THE JURISDICTION OF THE COURT TO TRY THE ENSUING CRIMINAL CASE AND THE VALIDITY OF SUCH CASE. That is the basis for the admission of relevant evidence obtained from illegal searches and seizures or searches and seizures that violate the accused’s fundamental right to privacy. In Nigeria, there is hardly any case where the jurisdiction of a Court to try a case is declared to be ousted by or the validity of the case declared vitiated by the unlawful arrest and detention of an accused at the pre-trial stage of the case or by any unlawful extrajudicial actions of the prosecution after arraignment during the pendence of criminal proceedings in Court.

The Court of Appeal has introduced a departure from the established case law on the point in Nigeria. What is not clear is if this departure is limited to cross border cases or includes cases within Nigeria. But the erudite restatements of the House of Lords in R V Horseferry Road Magistrates Court, ex parte Bennet (1994) 1 AC 42, (1993) 3 WLR 90, and the South African Court of Appeal in S V Ebrahim (1991)(2) SA 553 relied on by our Court of Appeal are couched in terms that suggest that they apply to all cases.

These profound judicial restatements appear to give paramount consideration to the prevention of executive lawlessness, protection of the fundamental rights of the accused, preservation of the rule of law, promotion of respect for the territorial sovereignty of states, enforcement of international law, adherence to the due process of criminal law, to ensuring the prosecution does not benefit from abuse of its power and abuse of Court processes. But the reality in Nigeria’s peculiar situation is that no allegation of commission of a crime would be tried if the Courts decline jurisdiction to try a criminal case or invalidate it because of the violations of the fundamental rights of the accused and other unlawful actions of the prosecution that occurred in the process of investigating a criminal complaint against him or in the process of initiating the criminal case arising from such complaint or in the process of bringing him to Court or in dealing with him in while he is standing trial in Court.

This is because criminal law enforcement officers routinely engage in unlawful actions and brazen violations of the fundamental rights of suspects in the investigation and prosecution of virtually all criminal complaints coming to them. If the judicial response to these unlawful actions by law enforcement agents against the accused is to refuse to try the case and invalidate it, this would result in a situation where the unlawful actions give the accused, the victim of the lawlessness a right to immunity against prosecution and trial for the alleged crime.

This kind of response would certainly build into a thick cloud of pervasive impunity for crimes and destroy the society. This is obviously not in the national interest. I think that the better judicial response is to hold the lawless law enforcement officers personally liable in damages and other remedies by civil actions and institutional administrative disciplinary measures and allow the prosecution and trial of the allegation of commission of crime to continue in accordance with the due process of law so that the objectives of Law and society of effective criminal law enforcement is not defeated. ?Be that as it is, let me emphasize that lawlessness can never be a legitimate and productive method of crime prevention and control. The due enforcement of law and order is the only effective, efficient and productive way to protect and preserve the rule of law. Crime cannot be committed as a valid means of crime prevention and control. When a Government established by law resorts to the commission of crimes as means of crime control and prevention, the rule of law becomes endangered.”

Per EMMANUEL AKOMAYE AGIM ,JSC

Share on
PLACE YOUR ADVERT HERE

Related articles:

US Court Sentences Ex-Police Officer to 40 Years in Prison for Sexually Assaulting 14-Year-Old Girl

A former Nigerian-American police officer in the United States,...

THE LEGALITY OF NO-REFUND POLICIES IN NIGERIA: EXAMINING CONSUMER RIGHTS AND THE LIMITS OF COMMERCIAL FREEDOM UNDER THE FCCPA 2018

  By: ONYINYECHUKWU UMEH Esq. 1. Introduction When you walk into a...